An Unpleasant Truth: The Blues’ Brutal Goaltending May Require Emergency Action by GM Doug Armstrong

I don’t overreact to regular-season hockey. The 82-game schedule encourages patience. It’s best to stay level and see how things evolve. It’s best to avoid leaping to conclusions when 50 percent of the games haven’t been played.

With one an injury precaution, Jake Allen has been replaced in three of his past five games.

That said …

After another bad loss — with the Blues exhibiting little urgency and energy in Tuesday’s 5-3 home defeat to Boston — I’ll take a little dip into the panic pool.

Is it time to freak out about your St. Louis Blues?

Well, I can only speak for myself … but I wouldn’t call it panic.

But with the Blues having played 41 games to reach the midway point of their schedule, I’m concerned.

Probably even alarmed.

Let’s begin with an overview look…

Blues’ apologists have regurgitated the company line by pointing out that the team, currently with 47 points, is only three points behind the pace of last season’s Blues’ squad. The 2015-16 Blues had 50 points through 41 games.

OK, that’s fair to mention — but it’s also misleading because of the Blues’ top-heavy home schedule to date. At the halfway mark last season, the Blues had played 22 home games — compared to 25 at home so far this season.

Plus: the Blues’ strength of schedule ranked 16th last season; so far this season the Blues’ SOS ranks 21st.

The Blues have had a favorable set of circumstances (schedule) that’s made it easier to pile up points.

The Western Conference standings aren’t as forgiving …

First of all, the NHL Central Division is stronger at the top.

The Blues’ current points total can’t be viewed as an isolated matter; it is relative to what other teams are doing.

Through 41 games last season the Blues led the NHL Central with 50 points and were No. 3 overall in the West.

Though 41 this season the Blues are in third place in the Central — and the gap is growing. The Blues trail first-place Chicago by 12 points and second-place Minnesota by eight points.

Meanwhile, the Blues haven’t created much space between themselves and the teams chasing them.

Here’s what I mean:

Through 41 games last season, the Blues were 10 points ahead of the No. 7 team in the West …

And 11 points ahead of the No. 8 and 9 teams …

And 12 points ahead of teams at No. 10 through No. 12.

This season through 41 games the Blues are only one point ahead of the No. 7 team in the West …

And only two points ahead of the No. 8 and No. 9 teams …

And only four points above the No. 10 and 11 teams …

And a mere five points in front of the No. 12 team in the West.

When we frame this by using last season’s midway progress report, 2016-2017 Blues are staring at a larger deficit when looking up at the teams ahead of them …

And on the opposite end, the Blues have a much smaller cushion that separates them from teams that sit below them in the conference standings.

And now, for the really disturbing trend …

More than anything the foundation of Ken Hitchcock’s system — goal prevention — is cracking. I’ve talked about this many times already this season, but the flaw can’t be emphasized enough. The situation is getting worse, and it’s a legitimate reason for worry.

Some bullet points for your consideration:

— The Blues’ goaltending is terrible. Jake Allen has basically broken down, getting yanked in three of his last five starts (one as an injury precaution.) Backup Carter Hutton was good in relief against the Bruins, but he’s been mostly subpar in most of his relief starts.

— Over at there’s a metric — quality-start percentage — that presents a quick assessment of a goaltender’s consistency. A rate of 60 percent is considered good. Fifty percent (or worse) is considered bad. Allen’s quality start percentage, 50%, ranks 18th among 21 NHL goaltenders that have started at least 25 games. Hutton’s quality-start percentage, 33.3%, is awful.

— Last season Allen had a quality-start rate of 59 percent. Brian Elliott’s quality-start percentage was 68.4 percent. As a tandem, Allen and Elliott had a quality-start percentage of 63.4%. This season, the Elliott-Hutton tandem has a quality-start percentage of 46.3%. That’s a drop in quality of 22.1 percent. I don’t know about you, but I think that’s a pretty substantial concern.

— Allen had six “really bad starts” all of last season. (That stat, and phrased, was coined by Hockey Reference.) Allen already has  seven  really bad starts at the halfway checkpoint this season.

— Allen isn’t coming up big as often in making close-range, high-danger saves. Over the past two seasons combined, on shots fired at him from a distance ranging between 1 and 15 feet, Allen had a save percentage of .847. This season, Allen’s save percentage is .795 on those close-range shots. That’s a significant drop.

— Last season the Blues gave up an average of 1.84 even-strength goals per game; that was tied for seventh-best in the league. This season the Blues are yielding 2.34 even-strength goals per game; that ranks 29th in the NHL and represents an increase of 27.1 percent from last season. That’s another eye-opening number.

— Last season the Blues ranked No. 1 in save percentage at .919; this season they have the NHL’s worst save percentage at .893. Over the last 17 seasons only two Blues teams finished with a worse save percentage. One was the the .887 save percentage posted by the dreadful 2005-2006 team that finished with the third-worst winning percentage in 49 seasons of Blues hockey.

— Last season the Blues surrendered 2.40 goals per game overall; that ranked No. 4 in the league. This season they’ve been invaded for 2.98 goals per contest which ranks 24th.

A more treacherous path on the road ahead …

The Blues are entering a critical stage of the season. A schedule-friendly first half, front-loaded with home games, now flips into an opposite direction, with a load of second-half road games. After having 25 of their first 41 games this season at home, the Blues will play 25 of 41 on the road.

The Blues have been horrible on the road so far, with a 5-10-1 record and a .344 winning percentage that ranks 28th among the 30 NHL teams. The road slog begins Thursday night in Los Angeles, with the Blues opening a stretch of six road games (and two at home) between now and Jan. 26.

Again, this team just isn’t the same, so don’t try to sell me on the idea that it is the same.

Sure-handed goaltending and rigid goal preventions were primary reasons why the 2015-2016 Blues had such a great winning percentage (.671) on the road last season. Only two NHL teams had a more impressive road winning percentage in 2015-16.

Last season’s road save percentage (.920) ranked third. Last season’s road goals-against average (2.46) ranked 6th.

This season? The Blues have the league’s worst road save percentage (.870) and are allowing more goals per game on the road (3.69) than any NHL team.

Wasting an uptick in offensive production …

The Blues are failing to take advantage of an upturn in their own scoring. After ranking 15th in goals per game (2.67) last season, the 2016-2017 Blues rank No. 8 in the league with an average of 2.83 goals per game. Despite scoring more often the Blues are a wallowing at minus 10 in even-strength differential because of their blatantly inadequate goaltending and loose defensive play.

When a team that traditionally specializes in playing tough and keeping pucks out of its own net is suddenly soft and frequently exploited by opponents’ goal scorers, it’s a serious change and a dramatic weakness that will only lead to disappointment and failure.

There’s still plenty of time for clean-up, but the Blues can’t afford to be exposed for much longer.

“He’s not stopping the puck,” Hitchcock said of Allen. “He’s having a tough go of it. We can just jump all over him or rally around him. We have a choice. He’s having a tough time right now … he’s having a real tough go and I don’t think anybody anticipated this, him or us. It is what is, we have to deal with it.”

If the goaltending continues to flop … then what?

If Allen can’t settle in and turn in quality performances on a more consistent basis, Blues GM Doug Armstrong may have no choice but to pull back from his commitment to Allen and acquire goaltending help by the Feb. 28 NHL trade deadline. This would require an embarrassing acknowledgement by team management — that Jake Allen isn’t who they thought he was. But at some point — soon — the Blues will have to have to do an immensely better job of stopping the puck if they want to stop their bleeding.

Thanks for reading …


More: Miklasz – We Can Make it Official: Clemson’s Dabo Swinney Is a Great Coach.

  • BillP

    The emergency action is to get a GM that actually knows how to build championship roster. This is needed more than anything before Doug takes this thing further off course. The Blues need a strong GM more than anything else right now. He is not the guy.

  • Ken Provencher

    The quality of players has taken a fall this year and for a salary cap team it points to the GM. There are way to many long term contracts that are hand cuffing this team and to go after a qualified goalie at this point would be a waste. A close look at what the GM is doing to assess talent and reward players is warranted by the owner. Armstrong needs to answer for what he has created.

    • Brent Staulcup

      The question is what is the market value of these players they’re giving the money to? Are other teams paying this kind of money for similar players?

  • Wyatt Evans

    Great goaltending is very hard to find. Even harder still after the GM forked over a 4 year/$17.4m unearned deal to Allen. Why did Armstrong think he simply HAD to jump in a year early and lock up Allen? Was he watching MO and the Kolten Wong experiment and said “Hey, giving away leverage and years looks smart!)

    Why does he continually go beyond what is necessary(see Patrik Berglund and Gunnarson’s contracts for more evidence)?

    So, I disagree with trying to get a goaltender at the trade deadline. DUMP Shattenkirk for whatever you can get–if anything now–and ride this creaky ship to April. Then, wave goodbye to Hitch, Armstrong, Berglund, Shattenkirk, Upshall, Brodziak. Call up all the youngsters (but not Ty Rattie or Hunt (probably will be gone after another idiotic waiver deal) and see if Yeo can create something with a core of talented players.

    50 years. Never won a SC let along a Finals game. 0-12. Horrible. And Armstrong/Hitch are not the answer. Period

    • Contisertoli

      Uh, nice tirade…Rattie is already gone.

      • Wyatt Evans

        Uh, way to read with intelligence. Yes, Rattie is gone and Hunt most likely will be lost the same way–through poor asset management by Armstrong.

        But thanks for the insightful post.

    • Brent Staulcup

      I’d like to see more of Hunt. Maybe, to some extent, he could fill Shattenkirk’s role, if they trade him.

      • Wyatt Evans

        Schmaltz and Dunn should be vying for the big club spots next year.

        I like Shattenkirk’s offensive ability. But he’s a liability on D. And for what he will be getting dollars/years, no way can the Blues compete for him. Nor should they.

    • Brandon Chapman

      I think one of the big reasons they double-downed on Allen was the “we don’t want to make the same mistake as we made with Ben Bishop” mentality.

      Of course Jake Allen is not Ben Bishop…

  • JeremyR

    This is really why I could never get into hockey – Goaltending seems to be 70% of the game…and then in the playoffs, it’s more like 90%. And the Blues have simply never had a great goalie, at least in his prime, nor one that got hot in the playoffs.

    I realize in baseball you can argue the same is true of pitching, but there it’s at least spread out over 5 starters and the bullpen, not one goalie and his backup.

    (And of course, keeping the number of shots down helps, just like defense helps pitchers, but ultimately it comes down to the ability of the goalie. Just like you’re never going to have Mike Leake win a Cy Young even with 8 gold glovers behind him, because he simply lacks the ability to be a great pitcher. The Blues have had a succession of Mike Leakes in goal)

  • Brent Staulcup

    The subtraction of Backes, Brouwer, and Elliott, has had more negative impact than anyone imagined. I’m hoping this is just a down year, and they can tweak the roster in the off-season. The core of young players is better than any Blues teams I can remember. I wouldn’t do anything brash to take a run at the Cup this year. Maybe pick up a journeyman goalie off the scrap heap. The exception being if they could get a premier goalie for Shattenkirk, but I don’t think that’s likely to happen.

  • BillP

    New book coming out: “How to ruin a Cup Contender” by Doug Armstrong
    Source of Reference – 2016 Off-Season
    –The book details everything a good GM wouldn’t do when his team is on the brink of reaching Stanley Cup Finals

  • CatfishRivers

    Bernie the Blues current goaltending situation makes me yearn for the good old days when the Blues had both Glenn Hall and Jacques Plante in goal (in the 1968-69 season) What a tandem! Two completely different goaltending styles – but both masters at their craft. Hall would go down to his knees a lot while Plante was a stand-up goalie that cut down on the angles.

  • Jim Parisi

    The team play has to improve on both sides of the puck too. Allen has sucked but so has the play in front of him. Strange year so far and you have to think losing Backes hurt the locker room. Should Steen have gotten the C instead of Pietrangelo?